Civic Issues
Topics getting the most attention in New Smyrna Beach public meetings, ranked by how frequently they are discussed.
19 issues with low priority
Risk protection order lawsuit — city insurance now covering
A Florida gun-rights nonprofit sued the city and six other Volusia jurisdictions over the local forms police used to file risk protection orders. Good news: the Florida League of Cities insurance is now picking up the defense, so the outside-counsel retainer hired last week is being terminated.
School-adjacent fence privacy at 4017 Saxon Drive
A homeowner wants an 8-foot fence because Coronado Elementary cleared its vegetation buffer and built its fence well inside its own property line, leaving homes exposed to school grounds. The board found the hardship wasn't the homeowner's doing and approved it unanimously.
Annexations: 670 Williams Road and Alberta/Louella
Two parcels — 6.63 acres at 670 Williams Road and 1.94 acres at Alberta and Louella Streets — are being brought into the city with rural/agricultural zoning. Hearings are October 27.
Paige Avenue conservation redesignation
City-owned land on Paige Avenue is slated to change from Medium Density Residential to Conservation, protecting it from development.
Cherry Street Easement Cleanup
Chuck and Carol Llewellyn say the city cleared an overgrown easement across from their home but left the area looking 'like the surface of the moon,' knocked down a post, and they want it cleaned up.
Beachside Baptist Fall Festival Neighborhood Impacts
A church festival drawing 900+ people to tiny Pine Street split the commission 4-1. Commissioner Martin says it's unfair to the neighborhood; others point to off-site parking, shuttles, and no complaints after last year's event.
Planning Consultant Fees Under Scrutiny
Landscape architect Walter Bone told the commission the four planning firms' fees run 25-45% above state averages, with no local presence, and urged adding a local liaison firm to contracts.
Farmer's Market MOU Renewal
The five-year Farmer's Market deal sailed through on consent, but two speakers flagged a new city indemnity clause, no attorney sign-off, a single vegetable vendor monopoly, and off-site signage with no sign plan.
Board's proactive role in code review
Members Causey and Bien want the board to flag emerging issues — like accessory dwelling units and data centers — to the Commission before cases arrive, rather than only reacting to applications.
Reconsideration of denied variance after notice concerns
The board agreed to rehear the denied 811 E. 15th Avenue shed variance in October after the applicant hired an attorney and flagged possible notice problems — a reminder that due process matters even for small projects.
Flagler Avenue rooster population
Nobody knows where the roosters roaming Flagler Avenue came from, but the neighborhood is divided on them — likely abandoned pets that keep breeding. The city may add language allowing removal of aggressive roosters after two verified attack reports.
Beachway Avenue public right-of-way
A fight over whether two homeowners can pave the public shell road right-of-way for their driveways. Approved with signage, but residents worry it looks and feels privatized.
Board self-review of roles and responsibilities
A member proposed the board review its own duties under city guidelines 302.00-302.01 at a future meeting, with written questions due in advance.
Limits on using CRA funds for flood control
A resident suggested CRA money might be better spent on flooding improvements. Staff explained state law bars CRA funds for stormwater projects already on the city's capital projects list, though some non-listed dredging projects are being funded with CRA money.
Possible rebranding as Jack Bolt Field
Staff floated flipping the airport name to emphasize Jack Bolt Field over New Smyrna Beach Municipal. Board members voiced early support, with a possible vote at a future meeting.
991 Hill Street coastal setback variance
A homeowner wants a pool deck east of the coastal construction setback line; both neighbors are already farther east behind a seawall, so the board approved unanimously.
233 Quay Assisi front setback variance
A retiree couple wants garages to encroach about 10 feet into the 35-foot front setback on an odd pie-shaped Venetia lot, partly to save a mature oak. Staff said none of the variance criteria were met; the board approved anyway, 4-3.
Preservation of The Magnolia (former Woman's Club)
A new documentary celebrates the saving of the century-old New Smyrna Woman's Club, which was nearly demolished before Curtis and Laura Hodges bought and meticulously restored it — a story organizers hope will inspire more preservation citywide.
Proposed data center prohibition
Commissioner Martin asked colleagues to consider drafting an ordinance banning data centers in the city — consensus only, no vote yet.