Civic Issues
Topics getting the most attention in New Smyrna Beach public meetings, ranked by how frequently they are discussed.
33 issues in zoning
North Causeway corridor master plan
Over 100 residents showed up Monday for the first of two workshops on what the North Causeway and South Causeway corridors should become — placemaking, not blank-slate development. Another session runs Wednesday at 5:30 p.m. at the Branco Center.
Building height definition review
The city's code excludes 'stairways and elevator penthouses' from building height, but staff has long held accessory structures to 25 feet anyway. The board's appeal decision means the definition will now be reviewed and likely clarified citywide.
Annexation and conservation of 835 Bay Drive parcel
The city wants to formally absorb land it already owns along Turnbull Creek and lock it in as Conservation. The planning board's recommendation now goes to the City Commission for a final decision.
School-adjacent fence privacy at 4017 Saxon Drive
A homeowner wants an 8-foot fence because Coronado Elementary cleared its vegetation buffer and built its fence well inside its own property line, leaving homes exposed to school grounds. The board found the hardship wasn't the homeowner's doing and approved it unanimously.
Commission authority over historic district alterations
Commissioners vented about projects like a two-story metal garage behind a 1920s home on Faulkner Street and asked what power the commission really has. Staff explained state law blocks design regulation of homes unless owners opt into local landmark status or local historic districts — of which the city currently has none.
Paige Avenue conservation redesignation
City-owned land on Paige Avenue is slated to change from Medium Density Residential to Conservation, protecting it from development.
Annexations: 670 Williams Road and Alberta/Louella
Two parcels — 6.63 acres at 670 Williams Road and 1.94 acres at Alberta and Louella Streets — are being brought into the city with rural/agricultural zoning. Hearings are October 27.
R-2 setback variance on E. 15th Avenue
A homeowner rebuilt a decades-old workshop without permits and it now sits too close to property lines for R-2 zoning. The board had to weigh the improvement over the old structure against the need to enforce setback rules on rebuilt buildings.
Beachside church rebuild rules (Ordinance 25-26)
A church festival drawing 900+ people to tiny Pine Street split the commission 4-1. Commissioner Martin says it's unfair to the neighborhood; others point to off-site parking, shuttles, and no complaints after last year's event.
Repeat code violations at short-term rental and venue properties
Two related properties on Hill Street and South Atlantic Avenue are being marketed as event venues in single-family residential zones — a use the city prohibits. Daily fines are now running until the advertising stops.
Board's proactive role in code review
Members Causey and Bien want the board to flag emerging issues — like accessory dwelling units and data centers — to the Commission before cases arrive, rather than only reacting to applications.
Reconsideration of denied variance after notice concerns
The board agreed to rehear the denied 811 E. 15th Avenue shed variance in October after the applicant hired an attorney and flagged possible notice problems — a reminder that due process matters even for small projects.
Data center regulation
With state legislation looming, Commissioner Martin won consensus asking staff to draft local data-center regulations before the state preempts local control. City Manager Cowper said staff is studying the issue deliberately and will bring a recommendation in the coming months.
67 Cunningham Drive flood-elevation variance
A waterfront homeowner asked to skip the city's extra one-foot flood requirement for a major addition. Granting it counts as a compliance error under the city's FEMA Community Rating System, which gives all residents flood-insurance discounts — the board approved it anyway, 5-0.
Annexation of SR 44 corridor and Spruce Street parcels
Two tiny parcels (~0.17 acres each) on Spruce Street move toward annexation with medium-density residential land use and R-2A zoning; second reading September 8.
Permitless rebuild leads to variance denial and code case
Two property owners in the trades rebuilt a 280-square-foot workshop at 811 E. 15th Ave. without pulling permits, closer to the side property line than allowed. The board denied relief 3-4, noting the owners should have known better and the variance criteria weren't met.
991 Hill Street coastal setback variance
A homeowner wants a pool deck east of the coastal construction setback line; both neighbors are already farther east behind a seawall, so the board approved unanimously.
233 Quay Assisi front setback variance
A retiree couple wants garages to encroach about 10 feet into the 35-foot front setback on an odd pie-shaped Venetia lot, partly to save a mature oak. Staff said none of the variance criteria were met; the board approved anyway, 4-3.
Historic West Side recognition — Allen Chapel AME Church
A longtime resident asked the commission to recognize the historic West Side, including Allen Chapel AME Church (organized 1891), one of the first two churches in the railroad settlement, and to help document its history for grant applications.
Historic preservation vs. redevelopment — Orlando moratorium discussion
Commissioners flagged Orlando's new vote letting developers bypass its historic preservation board, and asked staff to prepare a presentation on how New Smyrna Beach's rules protect (or don't protect) historic buildings here — including why a metal building went up behind a Faulkner Street home.
Retaining-wall fence variance near South Atlantic Avenue
A developer wants to fill four beachside lots and build a retaining wall up to six feet tall, with a three-foot aluminum fence on top — up to nine feet of height facing lower neighboring homes on Maple and Maralyn. Staff found all five variance criteria met, but one member saw the wall as a self-created hardship. Staff also flagged a possible future code change matching Volusia County's rule allowing such fences.
Proposed data center prohibition
Commissioner Martin asked colleagues to consider drafting an ordinance banning data centers in the city — consensus only, no vote yet.
Parking lots in light industrial zones (Ordinance 26-26)
A proposed change would allow parking lots as a permitted use in the I-1 district to address parking shortages — delayed to May 26.
South Myrtle Avenue rezoning (Ordinance 24-26)
An 11.37-acre former light-industrial site gets rezoned to PUD, opening the door to redevelopment neighbors fear will worsen traffic, flooding, and school-route safety. Residents packed the hearing; the Commission adopted it anyway, 4-1, with a stipulation the site plan returns for approval.
Unpermitted garage setback dispute on Nordman Avenue
A homeowner couple faces losing a 600-square-foot metal garage built six inches to a foot too close to their house and lot line after their contractor skipped the permit and disappeared. The board granted the variance anyway, 3-2, sparing them from moving or demolishing the building.
Minor land development code cleanup (ZT-0001-2026)
A package of small fixes: administrative variances aligned at 15 percent, parking lots allowed in light industrial zones, tree-fund flexibility, relaxed hedge rules, pool-equipment setback rules, and plat-language corrections.
Places of assembly standards in residential districts (ZT-12-25)
The city rewrote its rules for churches, schools, and similar uses in residential zones to comply with the federal RLUIPA law, which forbids treating churches worse than comparable uses. The new tiered system uses 'total daily users' to scale setbacks, buffers, and traffic-study requirements. Some residents worry the smaller 20-foot setback erodes neighborhood protection.
Comprehensive Plan amendments
Kimley-Horn is updating key elements of the city's Comprehensive Plan — land use, housing, utilities, conservation, and economic development — required every seven years. Board members want pedestrian and bicycle level-of-service standards included so new development can be required to add sidewalks and crosswalks.
Comprehensive Plan seven-year update
Kimley-Horn presented required updates to five plan elements, including potential accessory dwelling units, affordable housing incentives like density bonuses and parking reductions, and new state mandates on septic-to-sewer and solar. A formal vote comes at a future transmittal hearing.
Pool and Screen Enclosure Setback Confusion
Pools can sit 5 feet from a property line but screen enclosures need 7.5 feet — and pool permits skip planning, so homeowners keep getting surprised and forced into variances. The board formally asked staff to fix the code.
Porte Cochères in Front Yards
Homeowners on wide lots with horseshoe driveways want covered drive-up entrances, but the code currently blocks them from front yards. The board recommended allowing them with limits on width, height, and setbacks — now headed to the City Commission for a final call.
707 Cheston Street special exception
A dwelling unit can now occupy the second floor of a commercial building in the Light Industrial zone at 707 Cheston Street.
1300 S. Atlantic Avenue commercial-to-residential conversion
A 1.01-acre beachside commercial parcel is now slated for medium-density residential use after the commission approved the land-use change and rezoning 4-1. Dozens of residents spoke in favor; Commissioner Martin dissented both times.